HOME Netball Answers Netball COACHING Q&A

Intimidation debate - GK blocks view with back to attacker.

I'm very new to netball having grown up playing basketball and rugby at high levels and recently was getting taught by a 'more experienced coach' as this is mixed netball and the dynamic is very different. He said to the men that to minimise being called by umpires for being too close as the height difference percieves they're, one tactic is to turn your back and to get up close and to stare at the hoop. He said if he were umpiring he wouldnt count this for intimidation as there no eye or physical contact, simply blocking some of their view. I saw one of the men try this in a match yesterday and the umpire called them for intimiation? I'm trying to learn the margins as it seems every umpire/coach has their own opinion of this.Thanks in advance!

Billy Coach, United Kingdom

1 answer

ANSWERS

Annabel DunnillCoach, England

Hi Billy,

Whether the tactic your coach suggested is allowed or considered intimidation can indeed vary depending on the umpire's interpretation and how it is executed. It's essential to understand that the umpire's perception of the situation plays a significant role in their calls.

Here are some factors to consider:

Umpire Interpretation: Some umpires may interpret a player's proximity and positioning as intimidation, while others may allow it as long as there is no physical contact or eye contact intended to intimidate.

Consistency: It's true that different umpires may have different opinions and interpretations of the rules. As a player, you should adapt to the umpire's style during a match.

Balance: When using defensive positioning, it's crucial to maintain a fair and balanced distance. Getting too close can be perceived as intimidation, while maintaining a reasonable distance to defend effectively may be allowed.

No Physical Contact: Ensure that you do not make any physical contact with the shooter. Physical contact can lead to penalties.

Eye Contact: Avoid making prolonged and direct eye contact with the shooter, as this could be perceived as intimidation.

In netball, open communication between players and umpires is encouraged. If you have questions or concerns about an umpire's decisions, it's appropriate to politely ask for clarification during stoppages in play. This can help you better understand the umpire's perspective and adjust your play accordingly.

As you gain more experience in netball, you will become better at gauging how different umpires interpret the rules and adapting your playing style accordingly. It's important to maintain a respectful and sportsmanlike approach on the court while playing within the rules of the game.

Hope this helps.

Archie